[WhollySmokes]

I was looking at similar options. I test drove the S3 and M235i back-to-back and I was extremely underwhelmed by the S3. Not a fan of the transmission or handling at all. It felt too slow to shift and too disconnected for my taste. I know it's been getting great reviews but I just don't see it.

Before I test drove the M235i, I'd been hearing rumors that new BMWs had fallen prey to the same issue of feeling, "disconnected". I got in the 2, and was just blown away by the car. Handling, acceleration, shift speed were all extremely impressive.

CLA45 was next on the list, but I never made that appointment.

Just go test drive each of these for yourself. I'm sure it will be clear which one best fits your particular taste/needs.